Tag: homemade Poor Man’s Lobster

Poor Man’s LOBSTER

Poor Man's Lobster recipe made with cod.
Poor Man’s Lobster made with Cod fish, boiled in a seasoned broth, served with Paprika and melted butter.

Making Poor Man’s Lobster!

Poor Man’s Lobster is a cost-effective alternative to traditional lobster, typically made by using white fish like cod, haddock, or pollock. The fish is cooked in a flavorful broth that mimics the richness and texture of lobster meat. While it doesn’t taste exactly like lobster, the preparation and seasoning give it a similar experience at a fraction of the cost. This dish has been popular for years as an affordable way to enjoy the “lobster” experience without breaking the bank, and it’s perfect for anyone who loves seafood but wants a more budget-friendly option.

Easy Poor Man's Lobster with simple ingredients.
Top view of Imitation Lobster or “Poor Man’s Lobster”, as it’s worldly known.

The cost of Lobster vs. Imitation

While the name “Poor Man’s Lobster” might sound like a playful twist here in the “Poor Man’s Gourmet Kitchen,” I assure you, it’s the real deal. This dish has a long history and is a legitimate, budget-friendly alternative to actual lobster.  This recipe dates way back and it is a legitimate recipe and cheaper alternative to the real thing.

I can grab a healthy filet of cod for just $12, which can be broken down into over a dozen 5 oz pieces, perfect for mimicking lobster tails! You can also use haddock, mackerel, pollock, or halibut for this imitation lobster. However, if you’re going with halibut, you might as well just buy lobster, since the price is about the same. Either way, you’ll have a bit more cash in your pocket by choosing one of these fish and following this recipe, compared to shelling out for the real deal. A dozen 5 to 8 oz lobster tails can cost you at least $60, so stick with me, and I’ll show you a more affordable and healthy alternative!

How to make Poor Man’s Lobster video tutorial by PoorMansGourmet.

Poor Man’s Lobster Ingredients:

  • 1 Cod filet, Haddock, Pollock or Halibut fish
  • 1 pot of Water (approx. 1 qt.)
  • 1/4 cup Salt, mimics seawater
  • 1/4 cup Sugar, adds the sweet taste found in Lobster tail meat
  • 2 tbsp Lemon Juice (or ½ squeezed lemon), adds acid
  • 1/4 stick of Butter, adds a fatty lobster flavor
  • 2 Bay Leaves (optional), adds an earthy tea flavor to the broth

Instructions
1. Cut the fillet: Using a sharp knife, cut across the width of the cod filet, leaving 1 ½ inches between each slice. This will give you pieces that are about the size of lobster tail meat.
2. Prepare the boil: In a pot, add water, salt, sugar, lemon juice, butter, and bay leaves.
3. Add the fish portions to the rolling boil and remove, with a slotted spoon, from the pot as soon as each piece floats to the top.
4. Serve with a dash of Paprika and some Melted Butter.

Follow the video tutorial to season the water and boil your “Poor Man’s Lobster” for the perfect flavor.

Up Next: Poor Man’s Lobster

Different lobster tails that come from all over the world.
Lobster tails from different ocean regions, all over the world.

Where Lobster tails come from

Lobster tails come in a variety of types, each offering unique flavors and textures based on their origin. Warm-water lobster tails, often sourced from the Caribbean or South Africa, have a softer texture and sweeter taste. In contrast, cold-water lobster tails, from places like Maine or Canada, are prized for their firmer meat and more delicate, succulent flavor.

Some tails, like those from spiny lobsters, lack claws but are rich in meat, while others, like the clawed Maine lobster, offer a traditional experience. Exploring these tails reveals a world of culinary possibilities, each perfect for different dishes and occasions.

Boiled and seasoned Cod fish, used to make Poor Man's Lobster.
Imitation Lobster, known as “Poor Man’s Lobster”, made with Cod, a dash of Paprika and Melted Garlic Butter.

Poor Man’s Lobster is on the way!

Poor Man’s Lobster is a clever and delicious way to enjoy the flavors of lobster without the hefty price tag. Traditionally made using white fish like cod, haddock, or pollock, this dish transforms these humble ingredients into something truly special. The texture and taste mimic that of real lobster. In my upcoming post, you’ll learn the step-by-step process to perfect this budget-friendly seafood treat.

More Lobster Recipes

Stuffed Lobster, Tempura Lobster Tails, Lobster Sauce for Ravioli’s, Oven Baked. Lobster Tails, Lobster Rolls, Lobster Thermidor, Grilled Lobster with Garlic Herb Butter, Red Lobster Cakes, Lobster Bisque, Poor Man’s Lobster.